Losing someone you love is never easy, and finding out that their will may not reflect their true wishes can make an already difficult time even more overwhelming. You may be asking yourself, “Can I challenge this will?” or “What happens if I believe something was not right?” At Clyatt & Richardson, P.A., we understand that will disputes often involve more than legal issues. They involve family relationships, real emotions, and the desire to honor your loved one’s intentions. 

If you believe a will was affected by improper influence, fraud, mistakes, or other legal issues, Florida law may provide a way to challenge it. However, contesting a will is a serious legal process that requires careful preparation. There is a lot you need to know before taking legal action, including who can contest a will, common reasons for challenging a will, deadlines, and the steps involved.

Can You Contest a Will in Florida?

Yes, a will can be challenged in Florida, but only under certain circumstances. Also, not everyone has the legal ability to challenge a will. Florida only allows “interested persons” (people whose financial or legal interests may be affected by the outcome) to file will contests. This may include beneficiaries named in a will, individuals who were included in an earlier will, or heirs who would inherit if there were no enforceable will.

If you are unsure whether you have standing to contest a will, reviewing your situation with a skilled probate attorney can offer clarification before you spend time and resources pursuing a claim.

Valid Reasons for Contesting a Will

A disagreement with the contents of a will is usually not enough to overturn it. Florida courts look for specific legal problems that may affect whether the document reflects the true intentions of the person who created it.

Some of the most common grounds for contesting a will include:

Lack of Testamentary Capacity

A person creating a will must generally understand what they are doing at the time they sign it. This includes understanding their property, recognizing the people who may inherit from them, and knowing that they are creating a document that controls the distribution of their assets.

However, a medical diagnosis alone does not automatically invalidate a will. Instead, the focus is usually on the person’s mental ability at the specific time the will was signed. Medical records, witness statements, and other evidence may become important when evaluating capacity.

Undue Influence

This arises when someone improperly pressures or manipulates another person into signing a document that reflects someone else’s wishes and not their own (the testator’s).

These cases often involve looking at relationships, dependence, and what happened before and during the creation of the document. For example, you may have concerns if someone controlled access to your loved one, arranged the attorney appointment, or played a significant role in preparing the will.

However, not every unusual inheritance decision is the result of undue influence. Florida law requires evidence showing that another person overpowered the testator’s free choice.

Fraud or Forgery

A will contest is also allowed if fraud was involved. This can include situations where someone was deceived about what they were signing or where a document was altered or created using a false signature.

Improper Execution

Florida has specific requirements for properly executing a will. According to Florida Statutes section 732.502, the document must be signed by the person creating it, and they must do so voluntarily. Also, it must be witnessed by two people. 

If those formalities were not followed, the validity of the will may be questioned.

Timing is Crucial When Challenging a Florida Will

One of the biggest mistakes people make is waiting too long to explore their legal options. Florida probate deadlines can be extremely short, and missing the required timeframe may prevent you from challenging the will.

The deadline for contesting a will may be the earlier of 20 days after receiving formal notice or three months after receiving a Notice of Administration. Because these deadlines can determine whether your claim can even be heard, contacting a lawyer quickly is important.

What Happens During a Will Contest?

A will contest is handled by the probate court and typically begins by filing the appropriate legal petition explaining why the will should be challenged.

After the challenge is filed, both sides may need to exchange information and present evidence. This may include medical records, prior estate documents, witness testimony, communications, and other records that help explain how the will was created.

Some disputes can be resolved through mediation instead of through a full trial. However, if an agreement cannot be reached, the court can decide whether the will is valid.

Consider the Costs and Risks Before Filing

A will contest can be emotionally difficult and financially demanding. Legal fees, court expenses, and family conflicts are all factors you should consider before moving forward.

Before filing a challenge, ask yourself important questions:

Speaking with an experienced attorney can help you evaluate the strength of your case and determine the best path forward. 

How an Attorney Can Help

Contesting a will involves more than just filing paperwork. You need to identify valid legal grounds, gather supporting evidence, meet strict deadlines, and navigate Florida probate procedures.

Our team can help review the circumstances surrounding your loved one’s will, explain your available options, and help with disputes. Whether your concerns involve undue influence, fraud, or other questions about the validity of the document, having knowledgeable guidance can make the process easier.

Protect Your Rights During a Will Contest 

If you believe a loved one’s will may not accurately reflect their wishes, take the time to understand your legal options. At Clyatt & Richardson, P.A., our experienced probate attorneys are here to help you navigate the challenges that can come with will contests and probate disputes. Our team can review the details of your situation, explain your rights, and help you understand whether contesting a will may be the right path for you. You don’t have to face this process alone or make important decisions without guidance. Contact our office today to schedule a consultation and learn how we can help protect your interests during this difficult time.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *